Tag Archives: development
2024 Office of Planning & Office of Zoning Performance Oversight Highlights
- DC Office of Zoning (OZ) Agency Staff
https://www.youtube.com/live/pzjSzF2Ecls?si=0X5ewGKvSZ55UgJl&t=7374 - DC Office of Planning (OP) Agency Staff
https://www.youtube.com/live/pzjSzF2Ecls?si=hwGggDBlmXHA_Db3&t=14217
- Did OP/OZ's agency responses get at your problems and concerns, how? If not, why do you believe they didn't? And what's your follow up with these agencies or with the Committee to pursue the answers?
- Do you think we moved the needle in any way at these hearings for the people and for our interests in the city? How or why?
For me, the agencies and the city have no answers for (see attached print testimonials below for links to sources):
- 60,000 Black residents displaced in twenty years of #BuildingAsUsual
- Conservatively, there are 40,000 empty Class A housing units around the city right now — there is no luxury housing crisis (as if there ever was). We need affordable housing, social housing not luxury housing especially on public land.
- DC's definition of affordable housing IS NOT affordable for most people especially due to the immense racial wealth gap in DC.
- Parisa Norouzi, Empower DC
https://www.youtube.com/live/pzjSzF2Ecls?si=1owXIH1jsYXlJYNT&t=11994 - Anthony David, Racial Equity & The Environment, Empower DC
https://www.youtube.com/live/pzjSzF2Ecls?si=MX3-yc2Hj-IdLoCp&t=11822 - Andria Chatmon, Empower DC, Organizer
https://www.youtube.com/live/pzjSzF2Ecls?si=slp1rS2lTOvh-MGo&t=11347 - Sebrena Rhodes, Ivy City ANC
https://www.youtube.com/live/pzjSzF2Ecls?si=Xrm13Hi3GtnuE_zE&t=11136 - Shelly Repp, C100
https://www.youtube.com/live/pzjSzF2Ecls?si=qL1XRB4oWud7qipW&t=6076 - Chris Otten, DC4RD
https://www.youtube.com/live/pzjSzF2Ecls?si=AFHGwvzj3WcFBaz_&t=13138 - Historic Preservation, Rebecca Miller
https://www.youtube.com/live/pzjSzF2Ecls?si=_IderwN3JQ842u5h&t=13630 - Diedre Brown, Vice Chair NW Opportunity Partners (Ward 3) — Wisconsin Avenue Development Framework
https://www.youtube.com/live/pzjSzF2Ecls?si=3IqPQq4Irc_UpUFP&t=12473 - Parisa Norouzi on Map Amendments
https://www.youtube.com/live/pzjSzF2Ecls?si=GkpCcxQ5WOCPUrVf&t=6746
Colby King on Black Displacement from Washington D.C.
“The most destructive force to strike my native District of Columbia in my lifetime has been displacement: the forced removal of Black families and their community-binding activities and institutions from areas such as the Foggy Bottom and West End neighborhoods of Northwest D.C. and the southwest side of town. Displacement of thousands from places they had lived for generations to make room for new housing, better buildings and ultimately more affluent and privileged people.”
Opinion, “D.C. shoved Black neighborhoods aside. It’s still paying the price” by Colbert I. King, published in the Washington Post on January 19, 2024, https://archive.ph/5gxwK
The city's “poor folk [are being forced] out of their neighborhoods” by the city's “active role in development, selling or leasing publicly owned land, changing zoning laws, closing alleys and providing developers with inducements to construct new — or refurbish old — buildings … with resultant racial and class tensions.”
Opinion, “Quit the posturing in the Banneker-Shaw school dispute” by Colbert I. King on May 24, 2019 in the Washington Post, https://archive.ph/OSHig
“The city's growing tax base of middle-class couples and singles makes D.C. Mayor Anthony Williams giddy. The sight of “undesirable” neighborhoods being rapidly transformed into places where wealthier folks want to live makes Williams go weak in the knees. These changes are just what the mayor, his economic planners and his business friends ordered. Besides, there's no time for the displaced. The mayor's too busy with the National League of Cities and, when he's home, being wined and dined in glitzy downtown restaurants, Georgetown salons and the homes of folks he never thought he would meet when he was laboring as an Agriculture Department bureaucrat. The whole thing has turned his head. So what if booming property values and a richer downtown cultural life aren't doing much for renters or the evicted?”
Sources:
- DC Office of Planning 2020 Census Reporting: https://planning.dc.gov/publication/2020-census-information-and-data
- DC Council staffer breaking down DC Census at the Ward Level:
https://twitter.com/Blaine_Stum/status/1425885669113712651 - Overall US Census Figures, Filter by State
https://www.census.gov/library/visualizations/interactive/race-and-ethnicity-in-the-united-state-2010-and-2020-census.html - DC Census Shocker: Ward 1 Profuse Black Displacement While Ward 3 Grows in Black Population http://www.dc4reality.org/updates/669
Press Alert: DC Neighbors Want Proper Notice Abt Controversial Rezoning Project (1617 U Street NW — Police & Fire Stations)
Wards 1 & 2, Washington, DC — The Mayor has applied to rezone 2-acres of public land at 1617 U Street NW to allow 10+ story buildings at the public site in an area surrounded by two- and three-story historic districts with rowhomes dating back to the 1800's.
Despite the clamoring of opposition and desire for more engagement on the future of 1617 U Street, according to a neighbor's letter to the DC Council and a party's motion sent to the DC Zoning Commission showing that
the Mayor's Office of Planning and DC Office of Zoning have chosen to use outdated mailing lists that has left off numerous neighbors and properties from engagement, eliminating their opportunity to part of the zoning case and hearing this coming Monday, January 8, 2024.A motion filed with the Zoning Commission by neighbors says:
In all more than 40 different Property Owners within 200 feet of this site were not provided the legally required notice of the January 8, 2024 Hearing required under 11 DCMR, Subtitle Z, §402.1(d) nor did this Commission inform these 40+ Property Owners of “The requirements for participation as a party” and the importance of that status in a contested case, as required by 11 DCMR, Subtitle Z, §402.2. This upzoning is the prelude to DMPED’s attempt to have a massive 11 story, 650 unit apartment building constructed on this site. Failure to grant Property Owners their due process rights under the Subtitle Z in this contested case, is not only fundamentally wrong but will likely cause extensive and unnecessary future litigation.
Neighbors are asking the Zoning Commission to rule on the motion asking for postponement until proper and full notice is sent to all affected neighbors per the zoning regulations.
### ###
From: Arlene Feskanich <feskanicha@gmail.com>
Date: Fri, Jan 5, 2024 at 1:20 PM
Subject: Office of Zoning Case 23-02: Joint Motion to Continue January 8, 2024 Hearing Due to Failure to Properly Notify All Property Owners Within 200 Feet & Mailing List Used to Serve Property Owners Was from 2022 (or Earlier)
To: <abonds@dccouncil.gov>, bnadeau@dccouncil.gov <bnadeau@dccouncil.gov>, <bpinto@dccouncil.gov>, <callen@dccouncil.gov>, <chenderson@dccouncil.gov>, <jlewisgeorge@dccouncil.gov>, <kmcduffie@dccouncil.gov>, mfrumin@dccouncil.gov <mfrumin@dccouncil.gov>, <pmendelson@dccouncil.gov>, <rwhite@dccouncil.gov>, <twhite@dccouncil.gov>, <vgray@dccouncil.gov>, <zparker@dccouncil.gov>
CC: Arlene Feskanich <feskanicha@gmail.com>, Edward Hanlon <ed.hanlon.3@gmail.com>, Gregory Adams <adams.gregory1@yahoo.com>, Randy Jones <rjj0302@gmail.com>, Schellin, Sharon (DCOZ) <sharon.schellin@dc.gov>
From: ed.hanlon.3@gmail.com <ed.hanlon.3@gmail.com>
Sent: Thursday, January 4, 2024 4:01 PM
To: 'Daniel.Lyons@dc.gov' <Daniel.Lyons@dc.gov>; 'Jennifer.Steingasser@dc.gov' <Jennifer.Steingasser@dc.gov>; 'Joel.Lawson@dc.gov' <Joel.Lawson@dc.gov>; 'dcoz@dc.gov' <dcoz@dc.gov>; 'Brian (OAG' <Brian.Schwalb@dc.gov>; 'oag@dc.gov' <oag@dc.gov>; 'Alexandra (OAG' <Alexandra.Cain@dc.gov>; 'Lily (OAG' <lily.bullitt@dc.gov>; 'Maximilian.Tondro@dc.gov' <Maximilian.Tondro@dc.gov>; 'Niquelle.Allen@dc.gov' <Niquelle.Allen@dc.gov>; 'Johnnie.Barton2@dc.gov' <Johnnie.Barton2@dc.gov>; 'ashley.cooks@dc.gov' <ashley.cooks@dc.gov>; 'odca.mail@dc.gov' <odca.mail@dc.gov>; 'jlewisgeorge@dccouncil.gov' <jlewisgeorge@dccouncil.gov>; 'oca.eom@dc.gov' <oca.eom@dc.gov>; 'dmped.eom@dc.gov' <dmped.eom@dc.gov>; 'planning@dc.gov' <planning@dc.gov>; 'sharon.schellin@dc.gov' <sharon.schellin@dc.gov>; 'DCOZ – ZC Submissions (DCOZ' <DCOZ-ZCSubmissions@dc.gov>; '1b@anc.dc.gov' <1b@anc.dc.gov>; '2B@anc.dc.gov' <2B@anc.dc.gov>
Subject: Joint Motion to Continue January 8, 2024 Hearing Due to Failure to Properly Notify All Property Owners Within 200 Feet & Mailing List Used to Serve Property Owners Was from 2022 (or Earlier)
JOINT MOTION OF DUPONT CIRCLE CITIZENS ASSOCIATION,
HOMEOWNERS WITHIN 200 FEET OF LOTS 826 AND 827 AND RANDALL JONES
REQUESTING THE COMMISSION CONTINUE THE JANUARY 8, 2024 HEARING DUE TO
FAILURE TO PROPERLY NOTIFY ALL PROPERTY OWNERS WITHIN 200 FEET
—- continued on the record —-
———– click link above ——–
Interesting comparison… Community Surveys
—
Fwd: News Alert: DC Zoning Commission Waives Notice Requirements & Forges Ahead to a “Rulemaking” Hearing (in 2024) About The Future of the Chevy Chase Commons
DC Zoning Commission Waives Notice Requirements & Forges Ahead to a “Rulemaking” Hearing (in 2024) About The Future of the Chevy Chase Commons
Ward 3, Washington, DC, Nov. 9, 2023 – In a stunning rebuke to written public comments asking for postponement, including a letter from three Chevy Chase ANC Commissioners asserting that setdown of the Office of Planning's proposed new zones should not proceed “without the expressed view of ANC3/4G,” the DC Zoning Commission chose to waive notice requirements and to set down ZC Case No. 23-25 as “rulemaking.”
This decision by the Zoning Commission inches the mayor closer to privatizing public property currently occupied by the community center, library, and outdoor recreation facilities, even as ANC 3/4G continues to seek feedback from the community about the future of the site, via an ANC-devised survey. The majority of the members of the Zoning Commission are appointed by the mayor; and the Commission generally hews to the directives of the mayor's Office of Planning.
Zoning Commissioner and Vice Chair Robert Miller acknowledged “technical defects” but averred that “people know about this case going forward”. Chair Hood won unanimous approval from his fellow commissioners to waive the Commission's noticing requirements and procedures.
Chair Hood explained he was aware of ANC3/4G's community survey, to close on November 12, and stated that the Zoning Commission would take into account what the ANC drew from the survey.
The two custom zones for which OP is seeking approval (one for the site of the Chevy Chase Commons; and the second for the other Connecticut Avenue-facing lots between Livingston and Chevy Chase Circle) enable any projects that meet that custom zone criteria to proceed directly to permitting, thus eliminating future zoning hearings for developers and community members to engage in negotiations. Similarly, a “rulemaking” case is not subject to the vigorous public input that can take place with a “contested” case. These preemptive zoning actions are consistent with far-reaching text amendments proposed by the Office of Planning that squelch public participation in the zoning process (pending Zoning Case 22-25). — Andrea Rosen
Homelessness Grows At Record Pace Even As Oversupply Plagues High-End Multifamily Market
The rising cost of housing is putting more Americans on the street than ever before.
The homeless population in the U.S. has increased by 11% this year compared to 2022, according to a preliminary data analysis by The Wall Street Journal. Though the U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development plans to release finalized data later this year, anything close to the WSJ's preliminary figure would represent a record since HUD began its current method of data collection in 2007.
The previous biggest single-year jump in homelessness was 2.7% from 2018 to 2019, excluding the 2022 increase driven by a pandemic-affected undercount in 2021, the WSJ reports. The data collection method used by the WSJ and HUD, called a point-in-time count, routinely undercounts the true homeless population, but this year's preliminary figure counted at least 577,000 unhoused persons.
The single biggest driver of homelessness in the U.S. is rising housing costs, which persist even as inflation recedes from the rest of the economy. Shelter accounted for 90% of total inflation in July's consumer price index. Despite increased attention on the risk of homelessness for vulnerable populations, funding for support programs remains low.
Unhoused populations cluster in U.S. cities, but at varying rates. Denver's point-in-time count showed a 32% increase in homelessness, while Los Angeles recorded a 10% jump this year, the WSJ reports. New Orleans showed a 15% increase in homelessness, reversing improvements made in the first two years of the pandemic.
Despite affordable housing's scarcity, the overall supply of rental housing is increasing at a record pace, suppressing rent growth and imperiling some landlords that took out loans when the market was at its hottest. But that increased supply is vastly overweighted to the most expensive units, CoStar reports.
For at least seven consecutive quarters, over 70% of new U.S. apartment deliveries have been in the two most expensive rent tiers, CoStar reports. That trend is poised to continue this year, when over 500,000 more apartments are expected to deliver.
In those two most expensive tiers, rents decreased in the second quarter and vacancy rose to 9.1% after hitting a low of 6.5% in 2021, CoStar reports. In the Sun Belt, the reversal has been the most dramatic, with rents in the two most expensive tiers decreasing 4.5% in Austin, Texas, in Q2.
Contact Matthew Rothstein at matt.rothstein@bisnow.com
Redux :: DC Gentrification Lawsuit
The Feds Want More Housing! But what type of housing? Videos.
Fudge: “Everybody in the country knows we have a crisis of affordable housing. But the only way to get costs down is to assist developers and builders in building more homes. If we don't put more supply on the market the prices are not going to go down. … Help us find ways to deal with our zoning and our restrictions, so we can streamline the process.”
===
Questions:
- How does Ms. Fudge define “affordable” housing? Doesn't HUD say that folks making 120% of the AMI could qualify for an “affordable” unit? In DC, an individual making more than $120k/yr could qualify for an “affordable” unit under HUD's definition. Why is this acceptable?
- Is it true that the ONLY way to get costs down is to build MORE housing? What kinds of housing? Housing for whom? How about decommodifying alternatives: Social Housing, CLT's, etc.
- When she says, “If we don’t put more supply on the market, the prices are not going to go down” what parts of the housing market is she talking about – Do we need more single family homes, or more of the steady increase in studios/one bedrooms?
- Her statement about finding “ways to deal with our zoning … restrictions” … Is that a euphemism of ending community input and just allowing “developers and builders” to just keep building whatever they want wherever they want per the status quo without any basic planning protocols in place?
===
Contrast the above video, with this Adams Curtis video: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BAwH7R5ljo8
“This is the normal world. You go to work in a city. All around you are enormous new buildings. They look alike. You will never be able to afford to live in them because they are not really homes. They are blocks of money bought by global investors whose money has nowhere else to go.”
And, consider these points/analysis posts about housing production in DC:
http://www.dc4reality.org/updates/687
• Compare and Contrast: Growth & Displacement
http://www.dc4reality.org/updates/612
The eclectic reality of development, racism, displacement, and dogma in DC: Supply & Demand Ain’t It
- Dozens Of Tenants In This Rent-Controlled Building Are Facing Eviction, DCist, Apr 14, 2023, https://dcist.com/story/23/04/
14/woodner-apartments- eviction-tenant-union/ - Why the pace of rising DC-area rents has slowed, WTOP, March 20, 2023, https://wtop.com/business-
finance/2023/03/why-the-pace- of-rising-dc-area-rents-has- slowed/ - Without COVID-Era Protections, Evictions In The Region Are Ticking Up, DCist, Oct 11, 2022, DCist, https://dcist.com/story/22/10/
11/evictions-dc-md-va-rising- covid-protections/ - The D.C. Housing Authority Pays Top Dollar To Landlords In Wealthy Areas. Some Say That’s Bad Policy. DCist, Sep 13, 2022, https://dcist.com/story/22/09/
13/dc-housing-vouchers-rent- control/ - As Part Of Historic Investment, Bowser Announces Funding For 11 New Affordable Housing Projects, DCist, Aug 11, 2022, https://dcist.com/story/22/08/
11/mayor-bowser-announces-11- affordable-housing-projects- with-housing-production-trust- fund/ - D.C. development has soared under Bowser. So have housing costs. Washington Post, June 16, 2022, https://archive.ph/b7Lpi
- In a once-gritty D.C. market, these wholesalers’ world is slipping away, Washington Post, June 18, 2021, https://archive.ph/daQtm
- Capital Checkers Is Looking For A New Home After 40 Years In Shaw, DCist, Mar 8, 2021, https://dcist.com/story/21/03/
08/capital-checkers-losing- shaw-clubhouse/ - As D.C. Activists Push To Expand Rent Control, A Tool To Keep Track Of It Has Been Delayed For Years, DCist, Dec 21, 2020, https://dcist.com/story/20/12/
21/dc-rent-control-database- delayed/ - Facing Decrepit Conditions, Another D.C. Apartment Building Goes On Rent Strike, DCist, Oct 15, 2018, https://dcist.com/story/18/10/
15/another-brightwood-park- building-be/ - Interactive Map: Average Rents Increase Near 61 Of 91 Metrorail Stops, DCist, May 30, 2017, https://dcist.com/story/17/05/
30/interactive-map-average- rents-incre/ - Report: How Hard Is It To Find Affordable Housing In D.C.? Almost Impossible. DCist, Mar 12, 2015, https://dcist.com/story/15/03/
12/lack-of-affordable-housing/ - Median rental price for a one-bedroom D.C. apartment is $2,000, study says, Washington Post, March 12, 2015, https://archive.ph/kmlaj
—